Despite all the hype surrounding the original release of The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess, in 2006 I walked away feeling somewhat disappointed. Ten years later, the HD re-release has given the game a fancy coat of paint—as well as a chance for redemption. The return trip sheds light on the game's finer moments, which distinguish it as one of the best entries in the storied Zelda franchise. But beneath these virtues lie flaws and troubling design decisions that hold it back from taking the crown. Head inside to see what makes Twilight Princess HD such a difficult game to rate.